Evidence Room · Case file
Diligent Denizen’s interviews at a Panguitch, Utah, restaurant, what the staff say, and why he says it matters. Their claims, shown as claims.
Exhibit C
An eyewitness account that puts Tyler Robinson about three hours from UVU on the night before the shooting
Diligent Denizen (DD) interviewed staff at Cowboy’s Smokehouse in Panguitch, Utah. A staff member says Robinson ate at the bar there on the night of Sept. 10, 2025, and that he is certain it was him. These are their claims, not established facts.
Exhibit C · What the staff say
Their claims. An eyewitness identification is not proof. The owner says investigators never told the restaurant whether it was Robinson.
Exhibit C · Why DD says it matters
In his post, DD says Panguitch is 2 hours 49 minutes from UVU, so if Robinson left at about 10 p.m. he could not have reached UVU before about 12:47 a.m. on Sept. 11. He argues that does not fit the texts in the case, which he says have Robinson watching and waiting for police to leave for hours before about 12:36 a.m. His argument, not a finding.
Exhibit C · Not established
In the full conversation, the restaurant’s owner says that as far as he knows it was not Robinson, while his staff believe it was. He also says the restaurant had no working camera that night.